Pledge Manager
Return to your pledge manager order
30% off all in-stock items through November 20th! Search Cart (0)
Search Close
30% off all in-stock items through November 20th!

Sam Furst Collection

Filter by
Sort by Best Selling
Sort by
Quick View
Ghostbusters - Slimer Fear Freshener®
$2.80 $3.99
Sold Out
Quick View
Gremlins - Full Body Gizmo Enamel Pin
$9.99

1 review
Quick View
The Wolfman Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99

2 reviews
Quick View
Goosebumps - Splatter Wrapping Paper
$11.99

1 review
Quick View
Misfits - Holiday Fiend Fear Freshener®
$2.80 $3.99

1 review
Quick View
Krampus - Krampus Bell Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
Goosebumps - Slappy Enamel Pin
$9.99

2 reviews
Quick View
Holiday Horrors - Krampus - Gingerbread Man Metal Ornament
$7.00 $9.99

1 review
Quick View
Toxic Crusaders - Don't Pollute Metal Sign
$14.00 $19.99
Quick View
Gremlins - Stripe Head Enamel Pin
$9.99
Quick View
Motorhead - Ace of Spades Wrapping Paper
$8.40 $11.99
Quick View
Halloween 5 The Revenge of Michael Myers - Michael Myers Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
Misfits - Skull Wrapping Paper
$11.99
Quick View
Gremlins Holiday Gizmo Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99

1 review
Quick View
Holiday Horrors - Trick 'r Treat - Sam O'Lantern Pumpkin Metal Ornament
$7.00 $9.99

1 review
Quick View
Halloween 5 - The Revenge of Michael Myers - Michael Myers Fear Freshener®
$3.99

1 review
Quick View
Goosebumps - Haunted Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99

1 review
Quick View
Misfits - Remember Halloween Fiend Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
Gremlins Peltzer Workshop Metal Sign
$10.00

3 reviews
Quick View
The Toxic Avenger - I Love the Monster Hero Enamel Pin
$9.99
Quick View
Classic Halloween Sticker Pack (4 ct)
$1.75 $2.50

2 reviews
Quick View
Candy Corn - Pumpkin Pail Fear Freshener®
$3.99
Quick View
The Toxic Avenger - I Love The Monster Hero Fear Freshener®
$2.80 $3.99
Quick View
Ghostbusters - No Ghost Keychain
$8.40 $12.00
Quick View
Goosebumps - Slappy Fear Freshener®
$3.99
Sold Out
Quick View
Ghostbusters - Retro Keychain
$11.99
Sold Out
Quick View
Chamber of Horrors - Vintage Monster Masks Wrapping Paper
$11.99

2 reviews
Quick View
Misfits - Holiday Fiend Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99

1 review
Quick View
The Twilight Zone - Mystic Seer Machine Enamel Pin
$9.99
Quick View
Toxic Crusaders - Environmentally Informed Enamel Pin
$9.99
Quick View
Iron Maiden - Nights of the Dead Wrapping Paper
$8.40 $11.99

1 review
Quick View
Gremlins 2 - Splice of Life Metal Sign
$9.99

1 review
Quick View
Krampus - Krampus Figure Soap
$5.60 $7.99

1 review
Quick View
Candy Corn - Jacob Atkins Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Sold Out
Quick View
The Twilight Zone - Mystic Seer Enamel Pin
$9.99
Quick View
Toxic Crusaders - Logo Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
Candy Corn - Jacob Atkins Fear Freshener®
$2.80 $3.99
Quick View
Don Post - Satyr Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
Quick View
The Twilight Zone - Talky Tina Enamel Pin
$9.99

1 review
Sold Out
Quick View
Trick 'r Treat - Sam with Lollipop Soap
$7.99
Quick View
Candy Corn - Dr. Death Enamel Pin
$7.00 $9.99
1 in stock
Quick View
Trick 'r Treat - Sam O'Lantern Soap
$7.99

1 review
Quick View
Trick 'r Treat - Sam Unmasked Soap
$7.99
Quick View
Fallout - Reclamation Day Metal Sign
$24.99
Quick View
Fallout - Sugar Bombs Metal Sign
$24.99
Quick View
Candy Corn - Dr. Death Fear Freshener®
$1.99
Quick View
Fallout - Mr. Handy Metal Sign
$24.99